The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #124583   Message #2752373
Posted By: MGM·Lion
25-Oct-09 - 11:38 AM
Thread Name: Two puzzling amalgamations
Subject: RE: Two puzzling amalgamations
Young Buchan - Hares/Sally not particularly E Anglian, but widespread: Sedley's HotM in Seeds of Love, e.g., collected by Hammond in Dorset, collated with a Williams 'Upper Thames' version, tune from another Hammond/Dorset version.

Not happy about your 'easily': it certainly has happened: to say that it will 'easily' happen, so long as there is a similarity of format while no connection in theme appears to me to beg the question. We know that; but it doesn't add to the understanding of why it has happened so regularly between these two.