The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #125441   Message #2777513
Posted By: GUEST,leeneia
01-Dec-09 - 09:51 AM
Thread Name: Nancy me no nancies
Subject: Nancy me no nancies
Is it coincidence or something impish in the air that gives us four threads about songs with 'Nancy' in them at the same time?

The songs are:

And canst thou leave thy Nancy?
Lovely Nancy
The Wreck of the Nancy Lee
Queen of the Heather.

I said long ago, in a thread about 'Pleasant and Delightful' that it is an affectation of the upper class that country girls, especially saucy ones, are named Nancy. I still hold that opinion.

In 'The Queen of the Heather,' we find versions in old Scots dialect, then Joe Offer submits a version in standard English where the shepherdess has been converted to a Nancy. I feel that once the heroine has been converted to a Nancy, that song is over as a folk song.

Any further views?