Agree with McGrath. And with the Russian position, which is that it is a no-win situation.

A large part of the Pushtuns in Afghanistan have no representation in the government; most of the Taliban are young men of their group.
They are conservative, with an Islamic culture that dates back to biblical time. Treating them as if they were Al Queda is wrong.

Stepping up the war will cause them to back off for a while, but does not change their culture and they will be back after the troops leave.

The same people in Pakistan were left alone and caused little trouble, until the war stirred them up and Pakistan started to support the U. S. and alliance policies.

Recognition of their culture and guarantees to leave them alone in their area could lead them to expose the Al Queda members.

Obama has made a bad mistake.