Dear Bobert: So everything would have gone the same with no increase in troops? Yes or no?

And what is so scary besides the fact that the surge worked and you are dancing like a bug in a hot frying pan trying to deny it?

Matter of fact it worked so good that Obama is tring to claim it is one [one?] of his major successes. I don't see him claimin' that putting Sunnis on the payroll was one of his major successes.

Or maybe you spin it one way and you spin it the other way.

At least you are backing off of your "Hugo is da Man" attitude. That shows some logic.