Arnie-

Slippery slope. What if the person needing the transplant was a member of a political party you disapprove of? What if they were left handed, and you had had a teacher you hated who was left handed? What if they were a member of ( insert your own) minority?

IF you use other than clinical need, you open it to political, racial, and religious bias. Will you let someone else decide who is "Good" enough to get the transplant,or are we supposed to let you decide for everyone?


That said, I do understand your point. Perhaps a blanket "No transplant for anyone convicted of a felony" would work...

Worth a discussion.