The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #129250   Message #2900348
Posted By: Richard Bridge
05-May-10 - 02:39 AM
Thread Name: Distinctive Artist Covers of Songs
Subject: RE: Distictive Artist Covers of Songs
The Norman Greenbaum "Spirit in the Sky" was the best,

The Guess Who's "American Woman" was the best.

The Dixie Cups' Iko Iko was the best.

I've heard a cover of "Wipeout", but the Surfaris' was the definitive one.

The Troggs' "Wild Thing" is still the best although the version by "Fancy" (the lead singer was a Penthouse Pet) has a certain something.




I can't make up my mind about

"Shakin All Over" - Johnny Kidd and the Pirates, or the Who?

"Gimme Shelter" - the Stones or Merry Clayton?

"Blue Suede Shoes" - Carl Perkins, or Presley?

"Can't Explain" - the Who or Yvonne Elliman?

"Heard it Through the Grapevine" - the original, or the wonderful cover by Creedence Clearwater?

"You keep me Hangin' on" - the Supremes, or Vanilla Fudge?

"Proud Mary" - it could be the Ike and Tina Turner cover, not Creedence.




For the covers - there was a totally totally wonderful cover of "Wondrous Place" on one of the Toyota car ads, much better than the original done by Billy Fury.

I prefer the Creedence Clearwater version of "Suzie Q" to Dale Hawkins.

Bonnie Raitt's "If you gotta make a fool of somebody" is way better than Freddie and the Dreamers. So good in fact that I might do it!

"Walk me out in the Morning Dew"? - I think the Nazareth cover.

Manfred Mann's "Mighty Quinn" beats Dylan.

"Si Tu Dois Partir" I think beats any of the more Dylanesque "If you gotta go, go now" stylings





And which of the ten million versions of "Come away Melinda"?

Or "Get Ready"? - I might go for Donnie Elbert