The issue was touched on, on the Best English concertina thread. Which you may have read if you weren't busy making an fool of yourself by posting your own name to it.

Alan Day and others, including myself, thought it merited a separate discussion. Michael Sam Wild suggested Istarted the topic. And I did.

At the top of this thread I made it very clear I only used myself as an example and didn't want this to be about me. I am quite secure in my own situation and am not looking for advice. I am curious about different points of view, certainly given the few reactions I quoted earlier.