We've have a pretty good discussion thus far and I'm glad that people are mulling it over. It's worth thinking about. I want to make sure the reader understands the argument. I think at this point, it's been hashed out, although the reader may continue to post concerning it but I want to move one at this time and conclude the argument. My next post or two will deal with the afterlife by showing that--

a. There can be no heaven or hell.
b. The only logical choice is reincarnation.
c. The limitations of the argument.

And that will conclude the argument.

Whether there is a god will not be discussed because as some famous French guy told another, "I had no need for that hypothesis."