"telling me my argument is tautological or illogical or unworkable is pointless without a counterargument to offer in its place."

Josep, it is not possible to produce a counter-argument to something that doesn't appear to make sense in the first place. You know that full well. The three premises of the argument do not seem to lead to the alleged conclusion, and that is the only counter-argument I can offer. It is your responsibility to prove that they do, as that is what you are claiming. I don't need to prove that they don't, and until I hear a clearly understandable explanation to the contrary I stand by my comments.