I'm afraid that was me mis-stating josep's remarks... I try not to do that, but didn't take enough time to look for the exact quote, which was:

" My next post or two will deal with the afterlife by showing that--

a. There can be no heaven or hell.
b. The only logical choice is reincarnation.
c. The limitations of the argument.

And that will conclude the argument."


I interpreted that to indicate that he felt that his logic would leave no room for disagreement. Did I misread that, josep?