The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #133241   Message #3021623
Posted By: Jim Carroll
02-Nov-10 - 11:12 AM
Thread Name: Help: How to ID a Traveler
Subject: RE: Help: How to ID a Traveler
"True though Roma and Irish Tinkers are two different things,"
Yes - they are different; though inter-marriage and leaving the road to settle in houses has diminished those differences considerably in the last half century. There has been a tendency with the English Travellers we have met to overstate those differences in order to separate their community from other groups, particulary the Irish and Scots Travellers This has been mainly in order to scapegoat them and blame them for all ofences committed by Travellers, absolving themselves from such behaviour.
The truth is that you are no more likely to find a villain within any one given Travelling community; criminality occures basically from the appalling Third World conditions that all Travellers are forced to live, not their racial or cultural origins.
Iven if it were true that 'Romanies' were totally different from any other group of Travellers - so what - difference does not mean 'inferior' or 'more likely to be thieves and con-men' as was implied by Leadfingers racist statement regarding "Irish Tinkers, who , in general seem Hell Bent on blackening the good name of the Irish".
In today's world the term 'true Romany' has become as meaningless as 'True Brit' or True Anglo Saxon' or 'True Celt' - a form of sectartian bullshit to marginalise people from different cultural backgrounds.
Jim Carroll