The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #131699   Message #3021833
Posted By: Jack the Sailor
02-Nov-10 - 02:44 PM
Thread Name: BS: The God Delusion 2010
Subject: RE: BS: The God Delusion 2010
Sorry Smokey.

But that is not fair. John P. is asking for "evidence" that he will accept without specifying what evidence he will accept. I pointed out that 3 billion believers is evidence. He asked me to take his word that each and every one of those people were acting solely on superstition without offering a shred of proof that they were.

"Because I say so." Is not a logical argument.

He needs to prove his argument before demanding that I prove mine. That said, I can say right now that it is impossible to prove that there is a God or not.

>>please specify the proof that you require for your satisfaction and your rationale for not believing in all the other gods.<<

I have long ago addressed this matter on one of these threads. If you were too focused on your own "side" to remember, you will just have to do without hearing from me again.

Also Smokey. I need to point out to you that you have allied yourself here with someone who is clearly only here to mock and who travels the Internet to mock as a bit of a hobby. You have already received more reasonable attention then you deserve.