Ebbie - Given the ludicrous nature of the theoretical "choice" you presented him with, I'd have to go with number 2 as well! And this is why. Unlimited togetherness with a lover, either with OR without sex would drive me out of my mind! I need some time alone. Quite a bit of it, in fact. That's one reason I have never married.

Now, just wait for Spaw to list the other reasons! ;-D