"I've yet to meet someone who didn't believe in gods/the supernatural (or did, for that matter) who at the same time thought they were wrong or that they were illogical or irrational in their belief or non-belief"

I dont know if I am wrong or right in a belief in a God. It is rational for me, because it is what was instilled in me as a child, and at times gives me peace. Others may feel that such a belief is illogical for them. IMO, people are never wrong to hold personal beliefs, or not to have such. If it works for you personally, why would it matter to anyone else?