"...with reincarnation, while there is no evidence for it, there is also no evidence against it."

Hmmm... I'd say that IF you consider there to be 'evidence' against God, many of the same reasons would apply to reincarnation. After all, they both posit metaphysical concepts that require much subjective definition and speculation. Reincarnation assumes that 'something' hangs around after death...for some unspecified time in some unspecified place.... and then 'enters' a new body in some unspecified way. Sounds like a 'soul' to me.