I've never liked that part of the mag. The 2 things about it that bother me:

1) If you're going to slag off someone's work, please put your name on the review, so we can know your likes and dislikes over time, and judge your comments by your taste in music.

2) If you can't find something nice to say about a recording, why not use the editorial space to comment on someone else's recording that you *do* like?

Cheers,

Clive