The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #134382   Message #3058871
Posted By: katlaughing
21-Dec-10 - 04:42 PM
Thread Name: BS: And yet more abusing priests (Ireland)
Subject: RE: BS: And yet more abusing priests (Ireland)

Kat, it's quite obvious that you did not understand what I said about my reason for using the word "Father." At the time he committed his crimes, that was his title. I'd rather disown the man, but I have to humbly admit that at the time he committed his crimes, he was a priest in my church. My use of that term was my admission of that sad fact.


No, you misunderstood me, Joe. No one is questioning your acceptance of that "sad fact." What you aren't *hearing* is how hurtful it can be for victims to still hear such ilk called by what they are no longer, i.e. "Father." It was bad enough when it happened. No need to constant reminding.


And, how do you reconcile these two statements:

I don't really care whether people are punished for what they did fifteen years ago, as long as they're in a position where they cannot do it again.

and,

Saying that people were bad and they need to be punished, is not enough. Understanding is far more important than punishment - although I do not deny the need for punishment for crimes.

Do you want them punished or not? Do you really not care if they did it long enough ago?