I posted the original in March 2004. Most of the debate above I found interesting but I guess most people will not read the fifty odd responses. I guess we will go round and round the same points or maybe people will just not bother and it will die away.

I will repeat just two points to save people the bother of reading the collective wisdom of above:

1. The song has been changed since about 1950- 60.
2. It seems to me that nobody who posts her would sing racist, anti-semitic or songs advocating child abuse.

L in C#