The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #135090   Message #3112525
Posted By: Jim Carroll
12-Mar-11 - 03:19 PM
Thread Name: BS: Muslim prejudice
Subject: RE: BS: Muslim prejudice
This has become too much like a bloodsport for my taste - it would not have involved me as it has if the subject had not been racism.
As far as I can see, you have taken a stance that the British Pakistani culture is a degenerate one.
You have carefully selected your 'evidence' to prove this; on examination, that 'evidence' is little more than a sample of OPINIONS of people working in the field in limited areas (unspecified), and blown it out of all proportion to make your case.
You took the 'evidence'/opinion of your star witness, extracted the awkward bits, and presented his EDITED 'case' (43 times) to prove your point; blatently ignoring the warning of one of your own examples that there ws a danger that the cases under scrutiny were in danger of being used for racist purposes.
You have not even acknowledged the statements of the judge and the police involved in the cases, who have stressed that the crimes have nothing whatever to do with race or culture.
When your editing stunt was revealed you thrashed around and attempted to implicate others (me) in similar behaviour.
You also (as I predicted you would) seized on a mistake on my part (acknowleged by me) to suggest that I was a racist, similar to yourself.
I could go on.....
I have arrived at, and stated my opinion (or even confirmed earlier ones) of what you are and what you stand for.
Unless you can produce clear (unedited) evidence that I am wrong, I'm going to leave it there.
Whether or not you wish to continue with this 'farceathon' is your decision entirely - I'm done!
Jim Carroll