Keith it isn't evidence.

It isn't even unsworn testimony.

It is reports of allegations.

The problem here is that you don't know the difference - or lie to yourself about it.

One or the other, it doesn't matter.

You still have no evidence.

You are like a Banker creating derivatives based on a sub prime security.

It all looks very goood as long as the security is real, but it isn't.

It looks real, but when the debt is called in, or in your case when the evidence is checked, it all falls down.