The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #137879   Message #3154896
Posted By: GUEST,Shimrod
16-May-11 - 04:26 AM
Thread Name: Review: Sea Song prog. on BBC4
Subject: Review: Sea Song prog. on BBC4
Did anyone catch the programme called, 'Shanties and Sea Songs with Gareth Malone' on BBC4 last night?

Mr Malone went 'trawling' (sorry!) the coasts of the British Isles looking for sea songs. Apart from a fisherman's choir at Filey (?) what he mainly seemed to find was a lot of old folkies (I recognised a few faces) who sing shanties and sea songs - although the implication was that these were 'authentic' old sea dogs still keeping the songs alive (most of the songs were 'authentic' - I'm not sure that all of the 'sea dogs' were!).

He also interviewed a woman in Scotland who sang him 'The Shoals of Herring' and 'Cam All Ye Fisher Lassies' from 'Singing the Fishing' and the suggestion was that these were traditional songs - no mention of Ewan MacColl. In this section two genuine 'Fisher Lassies' (now in their 90s) were interviewed. These ladies remembered singing while they were gutting the herring in Buckie and Banff, or wherever, but the song that they recalled was 'I Belong to Glasgow'!

Watching this programme was like looking at the reflection of a familiar scene in a fairground distorting mirror!