The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #11200   Message #3180418
Posted By: GUEST,Ian Blue
02-Jul-11 - 05:52 PM
Thread Name: Sweet Afton - which tune?
Subject: RE: Sweet Afton - which tune?
I come from Paisley where Kenneth McKellar was brought up. I have always known Afton Water to be sung in the same version that he recorded ( hear it on Ebay) Its a beautiful melody.
This other tune from Alexander Hume or Spilman cannot compare.