The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #128220 Message #3181462
Posted By: Gibb Sahib
04-Jul-11 - 05:37 PM
Thread Name: The Advent and Development of Chanties
Subject: RE: The Advent and Development of Chanties
Looking at Whall's work here. I have not been able to see his earliest writings. However, with the exception of one or two songs, and with the exception of any bowdlerizing, I think his chanties represent what he heard during his time at sea, 1861-1872. His choice of what chanties to print, and what he says about them, does skew the overall impression, but that is a separate issue.
Whall first published chanties in two articles, neither of which I have seen. However, I presume that all the material from the articles was re-used for his later collection. The articles are:
1906 Whall, W.B. "Sea Melody." _The Nautical Magazine_ 76.
1906 [Whall, W.B.] "The Sea Shanty." _Yachting Monthly_ (October 1906).
The second article is reported to have contained 14 chanties. Among these were,
"John's gone to Hilo"
ACROSS THE WESTERN OCEAN
I have not seen the first edition of Whall's collection,
1910 Whall, Captain W.B. Sea Songs and Shanties. Brown, Son and Ferguson.
Therefore, I cannot say whether he added any to those 14, though I assume there must have been a few more -- that is, more *chanties*. The addition of non-chanty songs is given.
The preface from this edition (Nov. 1910) stated that, he did not consult other texts, and these versions were as heard. Deliberate use of "shanty" spelling; doubting French origin. Songs were harmonised by Whall's brother, R.H. Whall (a trained musician).
The second edition, 1912, added more songs. The Preface, dated Feb 1912, mentioned the popularity of shanties among landsfolk as the reason for such a rapid reprint.
The third edition contains no new preface, and I gather it to be the same as the 2nd.
The 4th edition adds more material.