Yes. I might try looking into that a bit more... Sounds like a serious issue.

(All the following is no knock on Emma personally or on her interesting blog BTW, or indeed on John Spiers ... or on anyone else (other than evil capitalist concertina hoarders obviously)) ..

I may be proved wrong, but I'm going to stick my neck out here - I suspect that what we have going on here is nothing but capitalism in action, rather than some nefarious conspiracy or immoral activity.

Concertinas have been expensive for a long time; I first came across them in the early 80s and would probably have started playing then if they'd not been way out of my price bracket then. (I did finally buy one years later and it was still a fair wodge of my money then) :)

Despite the excellent efforts of people like Wim Wakker and other manufacturers to make entry-level instruments, if you're going to play concertina there's nothing to beat a decent well-made vintage or modern instrument(*) - and they cost money, because demand outstrips supply.

Now if some evil person is found to be deliberately hoarding hundreds of top-quality concertinas to force the price high (presumably whilst stroking a white cat in their lair built into a dormant volcano) I'll be the first to join the lynch mob.

But I suspect that ain't gonna happen - because far too many vintage concertinas have just disappeared in the passage of time - they were discarded in house clearances, or fell to pieces, or got smashed up in the kids' version of piano-smashing contests, or just fell through the cracks of history.

Modern craft makers are just that - they make a certain number of instruments per year, and once they're sold, they're sold; and nobody to my knowledge has managed to come up with a way of factory-producing high-quality concertinas in the way that decent playable guitars are manufactured. And at the end of the day there's nothing like the economic imperative to do so, because there just isn't the same level of demand for concertinas.

I certainly haven't seen any concertina dealers or repairers driving around in Bentleys lighting their cigars with 50 pound notes ...


(*) I've said that before on Mudcat and been accused of cargo-cultism, but I'm saying it again here!