The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #128220 Message #3204926
Posted By: Gibb Sahib
09-Aug-11 - 06:43 PM
Thread Name: The Advent and Development of Chanties
Subject: RE: The Advent and Development of Chanties
1924 Frothingham, Robert, ed. _Songs of the Sea and Sailors' Chanteys_. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Contains a section with chanties (i.e. in addition to the nautical poetry that fills the rest).
The chanty selections look like they are based in various secondary sources, especially Davis & Tozer (the formatting of titles and such use it as a guide, at least), along with Masefield and RR Terry. However, the author has also taken the liberty of ~improving~ the songs a bit. Tunes are changed, perhaps based on what Frothingham believed they "should" have been. In "Tom's Gone to Ilo," for example, the contour follows D&T, but rather than the distinctive leaps between 6th and tonic, it has the major 7th degree in there – odd, I think, and contrived.
Did Frothingham have any access to primary sources, or any personal experience with these? He came out with numerous poetry/song anthologies on various themes, so I am assuming at this point that he was a compiler without significant first-hand knowledge. Would like to know more.
Hugill made use of plenty of the verses from this when harvesting for his SfSS collection.
Here is a list of the chanties. They are "typical", and, in my opinion, probably don't add to our historical knowledge of the genre. This evidently was, however, a work that was read and used as a source for later writers.
pg241. SAILORS' CHANTEYS [With score.]
LONG DRAG
[LONG TIME AGO] A Long Time Ago [BLOW BLOYS BLOW] Blow, Boys, Blow [BLOW THE MAN DOWN] Blow the Man Down [BONEY] Boney Was a Warrior [DEAD HORSE] Dead Horse [HANGING JOHNNY] Hanging Johnnie [LEAVE HER JOHNNY} Leave Her, Johnny, Leave Her [REUBEN RANZO] Reuben Ranzo [ROLL THE COTTON DOWN] Roll the Cotton Down [TOMMY'S GONE] Tom's Gone to Ilo [WHISKEY JOHNNY] Whisky for my Johnnie
SHORT DRAG
[HAUL AWAY JOE] Haul Away, Joe [BOWLINE] Haul the Bowline [JOHNNY BOWKER] Johnny Boker [PADDY DOYLE] Paddy Doyle
CAPSTAN
[GOODBYE FARE YOU WELL] Homeward Bound [SACRAMENTO] Hoodah-Day [SANTIANA] The Plains of Mexico RIO GRANDE] Rio Grande [SALLY BROWN] Sally Brown [HEAVE AWAY MY JOHNNIES] We're All Bound to Go [SHENANDOAH] The Wide Missouri
PUMPING
[ONE MORE DAY] One More Day [MR. STORMALONG] Storm-Along
OLD SEA SONGS
A-Roving Spanish Ladies Farewell, and Adieu to You Rolling Home High Barbaree The Golden Vanity