The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #140399 Message #3229266
Posted By: GUEST,beardedbruce
26-Sep-11 - 10:38 AM
Thread Name: BS: Palestine
Subject: RE: BS: Palestine
McGrath,
Why the pre-1967 borders? Why not the last ones the Arab states accepted ( 1923) or the 1972 truce lines?
Why are truce lines from the 1948 war more valid than accepted borders?
Or why not insist on the UN lines before the Arab attacks. THOSE would leave Israel with indefensible borders, and insure a new war, probably nuclear, within weeks.
And why has no one addressed the issue of the Jewish refugees form the 1948 war??
Shouldn't THEY get a land, carved from the Arab states?
And before you say that they have Israel, the Palestinian Arabs have Jordan and you don't seem to think that enough.
But then, it was 820,000 Jews Vs 640,000 Arabs- so of course you only care about giving the Arabs another state.