The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #140738   Message #3235851
Posted By: GUEST,josepp
08-Oct-11 - 01:12 PM
Thread Name: Is music-reading an important skill?
Subject: RE: Is music-reading an important skill?
What is on the written page is an approximation. This is really true of jazz. My instructor gives me jazz pieces to learn but won't tell me anything about them--just take them home and learn them. When I come back, I'm full of questions. One was a pattern that didn't really sound like anything. "You have to swing it," he said and played it the way a jazz bassist would play it. Smae notes but it sounded totally different and very jazzy. There's no real way to notate that. But now, whenever I see that pattern of notes, I know I have to swing it.

This thing I did at the coffeehouse, I was playing bass notes written for piano chords. I had to add in stuff that sounded double bassy because the straight notes off the page were too mechanical sounding. What was cool was that I could choose to play any note from a chord--not just the tonic. I could play a third or a fifth or a seventh which sounded very cool as long as I didn't overdo it and it gave the bass line some liveliness. Again, without the sheet music, I couldn't have done that.