The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #140399   Message #3238218
Posted By: Jim Carroll
13-Oct-11 - 03:39 AM
Thread Name: BS: Palestine
Subject: RE: BS: Palestine
"I am just asking for any evidence of actual complicity."
You are asking for evidence for an affair that, as far as most of us of us are concerned is done and dusted.
The fact that you have to ask "What enquiry" is evidence enough that you have not even bothered to read the links that have been posted - two enquiries took place following the events, one independent, one by the Israelis - I have no intention of doing your work for you - go and read them.
You are not "just asking for any evidence of actual complicity", you have given a conclusive opinion on the extent of Israeli troops involment in the massacre 'a failure to prevent it from happening' - historical whitewash, nothing less! That is not "asking for evidence"; it it an outright rejection of work that has already been carried out, without even bothering to present the reason for that rejection.
Where is your evidence for rejecting Fisk's latest work (he gave an on-the-spot report of the massacre at the time and has obviously followed up his earlier experience) - what are your ground for scepticism?
Apart from anything else, there is no reason to disbelieve the conclusions drawn from the massacre - you have a list of similar events actually carried out by Israeli troops - go and read them (and maybe challenge them).
I haven't followed up the Tzipi Livni/British Government affair - in 2009 an arrest warrant was served on a former Israeli Foreign Minister for war crimes, which she intends to challenge by visiting Britain thanks to the present government having changed the laws regarding war criminals - it would seem 'the beat goes on'.
It is apparent that we are not going to be given your "evidence" for "cultural implanting" of "all male Pakistanis" so we can safely assume that it doesn't exist and these are your opinions alone.
"Why are all your rebukes directed at me,"
Because of your persistence in making racist statements - Muslims, all male Pakistanis, Travellers "over-reperesentation in slavery - all grist to your particularly nasty little mill.
Jim Carroll