bonny george campbell is a song i used to sing , i stopped singing it to me it is a fragment, a pleasant tune, but storywise not in the same league as tam linn or willy of the winesbury or matty groves or reynard the fox.
I put in the same trash bin as lord randall, although it does have a better tune. john charles singing is pleasant enough, but to me the whole point of ballads is the story, when you have f### all story as in george campbell, its pretty difficult to interpret.