The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #141076   Message #3266020
Posted By: Jim Carroll
30-Nov-11 - 09:52 AM
Thread Name: Palestine (continuation)
Subject: RE: Palestine (continuation)
"I do not understand your post Jim."
Course you don't Keith - my point was to show that you have been supporting Israeli atrocities since at the very least May 2010 despite your claim that "I only put Israel's case on any issue AFTER Jim had exclusively put the Palestinian case."
I was not supporting the Palestine on the "New Israeli atrocity: attack on Gaza aid " - I wsa objecting to the cold-blooded murder of aid workers - which you were supporting.
"Well, if you don't want to be called a liar, then stop posting verifiably false statements"
I don't post false statements - if I have made a mistake I admit to having done so - I do not see the point of getting involved in discussion threads and doing otherwise.
You, on the other hand, have desperately tried to make this a racist issue on my part, failed miserably and moved on without having the good grace to admit you were wrong.
You have claimed that I oppose the Jewish homeland - failed miserbly to even to make an approach on this one - so you move on without having the good grace to admit you were wrong.
You called me a liar when I said I had responded to a question you asked - when I pointed out that I had, you moved on without having the good grace to admit you were wrong.
You have said that the Palestinians have no claim to Palestine, when challenged, you ignore requests as to what should happen to the Palestinians - you ignore those requests.
Personally I find it despicable - as low as anybody can sink for anybody to hide behind centuries of victims of anti-Semitism to defend the inhuman and criminal behaviour on the part of the religious extremeists who run modern Israel - it is no defence to point at other criminals who are guilty of other atrocities - you have operated an eye-for-an-eye argument throughout this thread - why not, you bear all the hallmarks of a religious extremist yourself.
This is a discussion about Palestine and the atrocities that are taking place there; Israell is the aggressor and its victims are mainly civilians; men women or children, it appears not to amtter to the Israelis and their supporters; killed, maimed, made homeless deprived of basic needs of life... for the pursuit of territory. That is a fact that is recognised throughout the civiliesed world - address that one insted of crouching behind the dead for your argument.
Jim Carroll