As part of my Liverpool Folk Song a Week project, I've just recorded a version of While Shepherds Watched that was collected by Lucy Broadwood with the note "Liverpool Version" - in her manuscripts in the Vaughan Williams Memorial Library its alongside another carol collected with the note "as sung in Liverpool".

While Shepherds Watched - 'Liverpool version' collected by Lucy Broadwood

I'm just wondering if anybody recognises the tune, or has heard it used somewhere else? (I'm pretty sure it's not the same as the tune known as 'Liverpool', in case someone's wondering!) I hadn't heard it before, but I reckon that other people must have a wider knowledge of the different tunes used for While Shepherds Watched.