I wish someone would tell me when these "what is folk music?" threads were coming up. Then I could sell tickets to the debate. they are much more entertaining than the presidential debates. But then so is watching paint dry.

Here is an idea. Since this comes up so often why not have a REAL DEBATE? We could have a moderator, choose sides, and set up a thread specifically for the debate.

Here's how I see it working.

THR GREAT DEBATE QUESTION: What is Folk Music? Side 1 [List of Representatives] Side 2 [List of Representatives]

The moderator would start with a list of questions. S/He would start off with a question and present it to a side chosen at random. Those on that list of representatives would get a day to formulate their position. On that day they would be the only people authorized to post to the thread. The moderator would then notify the other side that it was their turn to rebut. That side would also have a day to post. PM's, of course are encouraged for coordinating repsonses.

The moderator would then open the floor to discussion allowing others to post their questions and positions. This would also be a one day opportunity.

Then we reverse the process to allow the other sides to answer questions.

The time limitation for posting would have to be on the honor system.

What do you think. Do you guys have the guts for formalize the argument?