The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #145631   Message #3369592
Posted By: Big Al Whittle
29-Jun-12 - 11:42 AM
Thread Name: Nic Jones article in The Guardian
Subject: RE: Nic Jones article in The Guardian
yeh literature had Leavis, Tillyard, Wilson Knight. In folk music we had Karl Dallas and Colin Irwin.

Was it Eliot said, the critics job is to isolate quality? I guess we were of such quality GSS that we were isolated by those two - so that the barren wastes of English folk music could be presided over by their favourites.

It was their view of English folk music that was barren and ill informed.

I think it was me who said to Martin that open tunings were cheating. He didn't headbut me, but looked quizzically, then I said, what I really mean is that it becomes a substantially different instrument - when you move away from the EADGBE tuning. And he agreed.