Sage, you asked if anyone is still using turntables: Yes, I have a big linear-arm Pioneer that I have had for 27 years, and it is still in VGC. Diamond styli make a difference, and it cost more than a weeks wages once.   
For re-recording LPs to CDs, I'm using a new cheap Optimus which has a pre-amp so that it plugs straight into the computer sound-card. Nothing like the same quality as the Pioneer, but when the LP collection is 'done,' it will be surplus, and it sounds just as good anyway!