Peg: Check out the thread on Boar's Head Carol for some suggested recordings.

I didn't satisfy Alex's original question in my earlier posting. I like that CD (or just about any Robert Shaw Chorale recording) because I first heard it in about 1949 when it was released on a 78 RPM album. When LP records came out, RCA re-issued it on LP. Now it's on CD. My kids were raised on those carols and that album in particular, and Christmas just wouldn't seem the same without hearing it. (They also loved the Mitch Miller Sing Along LP also)

DougR