The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #147734   Message #3449729
Posted By: Keith A of Hertford
09-Dec-12 - 09:25 AM
Thread Name: BS: Vilnai: inflict a 'shoah' on Gaza
Subject: RE: BS: Vilnai: inflict a 'shoah' on Gaza
You have denied the pert the Israelis played in the massacre of over 3,00 refugees
I merely gave Israel's version of events, which you never want to know.

You have defended the use of chemicals on civilians, particularly children, even though you have been given the horrific evidence
It was not chemical weapons.
It was not any kind of weapon. It was smoke munitions, and I did not defend its use.
Actual weapons would have caused hundreds more casualties.

You have blamed the soldiers for the killing of civilians even though they have shown they were acting under orders

Acting under orders is no excuse for a war crime.
There is no indication the orders came from a high level, unlike the orders to launch missiles at ordinary Jewish people from civilian areas.

You have denied unequivolcal evidence that the Israeli blockade has caused malnutrition among a significant number of Palestinian children, despite the evidence produced by neutral international organisations on the spot.

No jim. You have denied unequivocal evidence that there is no blockade of food or medicine.

You have ignored the fact that the continuing obstruction of building and farming equipment and the building of a Berlin-type wall has caused extreme hardship among ordinary Palestinians, despite having been given documented evidence of these facts

I have not discussed the wall.
I have given evidence that gaza's farmers are exporting large amounts of produce, and only fertilisers that can make explosives are banned.


You have described as not only permissible but desirable,the slaughter of civilians if it is believed that Hamas fighters are in the area (OR EVEN IF THEY HAVE THEIR HOMES IN BUILT-UP AREAS.,

I have stated that IDF acted within International Law.

To top all this off, you have suggested that those who find all this atrocious are Nazi supporters

No.

"Perhaps you deny the Nazis' racist lies because you regard them as accurate?"
It was only Don who denied that Nazis made up lies about Jews to justify their extermination.
I did not realise that you agreed with him.