The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #32340 Message #3470158
Posted By: Joe Offer
22-Jan-13 - 06:46 PM
Thread Name: any new mondegreens?
Subject: RE: any new mondegreens?
I was in the "My Dear Mister Shane" camp, too. I don't think I knew otherwise until the song came into discussion at Mudcat.
As Tattie Bogle says above, we have a doozie of a Mondegreen in the transcription of Dougie MacLean's "Caledonia" in the Digital Tradition:
I have kissed the ladies and left them crying Stolen dreams, yes there's no denying I have traveled hard with coattails flying Somewhere in the wind
Here's a transcription of the MacLean recording that most of us have agreed upon
I have moved and kept on moving proved the points that I needed proving Lost the friends that I needed losing found others on the way I have tried and I've kept on trying stolen dreams, yes there's no denying I have travelled hard, sometimes with conscience flying somewhere in the wind
Now usually when I hear a Mondegreen that I know comes from the Digital Tradition, I can look at the singer's notes and see the song in the familiar Digital Tradition format. But this month, a Scotland-born friend sang the "coattails" version of the song, and he sang from tattered, handwritten notes. He didn't remember the source, but didn't think it came from the DT. I'm guessing that he and the DT got the Mondegreen from a common source.