Haven't seen it yet.

I was aprehensive about the LOTR trilogy, having loved the books, but I was duly impressed. I thought Peter Jackson did a pretty good job of it, all in all. I liked it well enough so that I bought the DVD Platinum set (director's cut, including deleted scenes, how they did cetain effects, discussions of making the movies, etc.)

On The Hobbit, I'm reserving judgment until I have a chance to see it.

Don Firth