The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #10547   Message #3488462
Posted By: Airymouse
09-Mar-13 - 01:23 PM
Thread Name: Gypsy Rover a real folk song?
Subject: RE: Gypsy Rover a real folk song?
my 2 cents 1st penny: I'm an old timer saddled with long-abandoned rules of grammar. I was taught to use AS for affirmation and SO for negation. For example, A is AS good as B, but not SO good as C. The only place I know where this rule is honored is Black Jack Davy. In every version I've heard the second horse is always "not SO speedy".
2nd penny: There is an interesting western version, called Clayton Boone I don't remember it exactly, but it goes something like this
P.S. It seems that when the Child ballads get to my country they tend to be kinder to the womenfolk. Another example is Almeda Riddle's version of The 4 Marys versus the older versions, where Mary Hamilton is portrayed as wicked an unrepentant.