The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #149360 Message #3490154
Posted By: Keith A of Hertford
14-Mar-13 - 06:09 AM
Thread Name: BS: Israel condemned by UN
Subject: RE: BS: Israel condemned by UN
Jim, Israel accepts that it bears responsibility. It denies complicity, and there is no evidence for it.
Ellen Siegel gives a full account of her time in the hospital, as does the doctor. They do not report seeing anything of the massacre.
one minute she saw nothing, next minute she was on top of the hospital building and taking long walks, viewing it all
You claimed I made up her observations from the roof and had to apologise. The long walk was from the hospital to the edge of the camp and beyond. She and the doctor were together.
You have been given her statement about seeing the Israelis burying the bodies. No. You have made that up.
"There were lots of soldiers who spoke out and testified at the time." Now you are openly lying again - you have rejected these statements as "unreliable" Not true. I am suspicious of the ones who only "remembered" long after.
Your quote from Dr.Ang Swee Chai is not a report of what she saw. It is her opinion of what happened while she was inside the hospital.