Your claims waver from – the medical staff did not know the massacre was going on to - they could see everything but did not see Israeli soldiers there, to how could they see anything from an enclosed hospital – to they had an excellent view of the camp from the roof of the hospital – to they never left the hospital to – they took long walks – flexible evidence to suit all occasions, don't you think.
A small selection.
"She was in the hospital throughout the massacres, and was unaware of them."
07 Mar 13 - 02:57 PM
"She herself had seen no signs of the civilian massacre from the top of her hospital deep within the camp, or during her long walk out."
08 Mar 13 - 04:08 AM
"The "eye witness doctor" did not even see anything of the massacres. She was with Siegel in the hospital."
"07 Mar 13 - 02:57 PM
And as I came out of the hospital I saw groups of women and men and children all rounded up by soldiers and while I was passing them one woman tried to give me her baby"
14 Mar 13 - 03:39 AM
"Why did they not come forward,"
A They where traumatised by what they witnessed; fully covered in the story of the making of the film Waltz with Bashir, based on the experiences of one of those soldiers
My father was a prisoner of war in Spain - I found out last year that he was taken out regularly and placed in front of a mock firing squad then taken back to his cell. He never spoke about the war in Spain until five years after his release - he didn't talk to anybody for a year after he returned home.
His brother my uncle, was one of the soldiers who entered a Nazi concentration camp at the end of the war - he never spoke of it to anybody; he'd written down some of his experiences in a notebook which was found after his death
That's what happens in wartime.
B Some of the soldier witnesses said that they had seen their mates disciplined for speaking up; several of them were dismissed from the army - a disincentive to telling what had happened until it was long behind them.
Others, of course, felt a duty to their country but, being human beings, could only live with what happened for so long - that came out in their testimonies which you have been given, read them.
"The militia took casualties."
Where are the reports – you are just telling us what happened, as you have throughout this thread – EVIDENCE.
"Siegel reports sounds of fighting."
You have told us Seigal didn't even know the massacre was taking place – make up your ******* mind.
"Bloody nonsense - there was no street lighting "
DO NOT BE STUPID – MASSACRE IN THE PITCH DARK – THEY'D BE SLAUGHTERING EACH OTHER.
If they needed light to, as you so revealingly put it "seek out their enemies" they certainly needed it to slaughter their victims – UTTER NONSENSE.
"I have given you mine."
No you haven't – you have just told us, without evidence – what you claim happened – you have had our evidence several times – READ IT
Jim Carroll