I've been through my second list now - songs with Roud numbers - looking for other versions which have music specified. The search was for music or audio and both are included in the list. For songs with many versions with music I have only included 6 of them. Unless it says that only some are shown, all the other sources with tunes (in the Roud index) are listed. I think 25 of them have other versions with tunes.
The lists should show all the songs with tunes of some sort available.
Mick
ADMIRAL BENBOW Roud number 3141
Chappell, Popular Music of the Olden Time (1859) 2 pp.641-643
Whall, Sea Songs & Shanties (6th edn., 1927) pp.79-81
Whall, Ships, Sea Songs & Shanties (2nd edn., 1912) pp.104-106
Palmer, Oxford Book of Sea Songs (1986) pp.82-84
Palmer, Boxing the Compass (2001) pp.95-97
BATTLE OF THE SHANNON AND CHESAPEAKE Roud number 963
audio: Topic 12TS 285 (`Green Grow the Laurels')
audio: Musical Traditions MT CD 311-2 ('Up in the North and Down in the South')
audio: Mike Yates Collection: British Library National Sound Archive C 796/89 (VWML 27 CDA Yates)
BILLY TAYLOR (A BURLESQUE BALLAD) Roud number 158
-- 150 entries with audio or music - these are just a few of them
Journal of the Folk-Song Society 5 (1915) pp.164-165 (18C sheet music)
Greig-Duncan Collection 1 pp.438-441 (version a)
audio: Leader LEA 4050 (`Unto Brigg Fair')
Sharp, Folk Songs from Somerset 5 pp.46-47 (Version a)
O'Shaughnessey, Yellowbelly Ballads 1 pp.13-14, 66-67
Karpeles, Cecil Sharp Collection 2 pp.63-64 (version a)
BLANCHE FRIGATE, THE Roud number 4583
+++ NO TUNES
BORNEO HEROES, THE Roud number V1666
+++ NO TUNES
BRAGS OF WASHINGTON, THE Roud number 22795
+++ NO TUNES
CAPTAIN BARTON'S DISTRESS ON BOARD THE LICHFIELD Roud number V1856
+++ NO TUNES
CAPTAIN COBB'S BRAVERY Roud number 7005
Tocher 6 (1972) pp.180-181
Stewart, Up Yon Wide and Lonely Glen (2012) p.218
audio: Folktrax 365 (1978) / School of Scottish StudiesSA 1955
CAPTAIN KID'S FAREWEL TO THE SEAS; or, THE FAMOUS PIRATE'S LAMENT Roud number 1900
-- 28 entries - these are some of them
Francis Collinson MSS Collection (VWML) Vol.6 No.83 (music only)
audio: Talking Book 2/1501/26 ('Windy Old Weather') (Bob Roberts)
(above are only 2 collected in England)
Peacock, Songs of the Newfoundland Outports 3 (1965) pp.837-839
audio: Edith Fowke Coll. (FO 64)
Colcord, Songs of American Sailormen (Oak Pubns edn) pp.136-140
Lomax, Folk Songs of North America (1960) pp.15-16
CAPTAIN MANSFIELD'S FIGHT WITH THE TURKES AT SEA Roud number 951
-- 14 entries - these are some
audio: Folktracks FSA 033 (`Jack on the Rocks')
Journal of the Folk-Song Society 5 (1915) pp.167-169
Vaughan Williams & Lloyd, Penguin Book of English Folk Songs p.91
Baring-Gould, Songs of the West (1905 edn.) pp.226-227
audio: Topic TSCD 512D ('The Bonny Labouring Boy')
Vaughan Williams & Lloyd, Classic English Folk Songs (2003) p.59
CAWSAND BAY Roud number 22827
Baring-Gould, Garland of Country Song (1895) pp.48-49
Whall, Sea Songs & Shanties (6th edn., 1927) pp.129-132
Lucy Broadwood MSS (Vaughan Williams Memorial Library) LEB/5/130, 131
Sabine Baring-Gould MSS collection: Personal copy 1: SBG/1/2/170
Sabine Baring-Gould MSS collection: Personal copy 2: SBG/1/2/169
CONSTITUTION AND GUERRIERE, THE Roud number 626
Colcord, Songs of American Sailormen (Oak Pubns edn) pp.126-127
Wolfe, Folk Songs of Middle Tennessee (1997) pp.54-55
Lomax, American Ballads & Folk Songs pp.507-509
Shay, American Sea Songs & Chanteys (1948) pp.161-164
Harlow, Chanteying Aboard American Ships (1962) pp.184-186
audio: Library of Congress: Archive of American Folk Culture 4202 A4
audio: Library of Congress AAFS recording 423 A3
audio: Helen Hartness Flanders Collection (Middlebury College, Vermont) D31 A 06
audio: Helen Hartness Flanders Collection (Middlebury College, Vermont) D27 A 04
audio: Helen Hartness Flanders Collection (Middlebury College, Vermont) T8 A 03
DEATH OF ADMIRAL BENBOW, THE Roud number 227
-- 24 entries - these are some of them
Copper, Song for Every Season (1971) pp.266-267
Journal of the Folk-Song Society 2 (1906) pp.236-238
Karpeles, Cecil Sharp Collection 2 pp.273-274
audio: BBC recording 9467
audio: Folktracks FSA 098 (`The Greenwood Side-I-O')
Anne Gilchrist MSS Collection (Vaughan Williams Memorial Library) AGG/7/269
DEATH OF PARKER, THE Roud number 1032
-- 14 entries - these are some of them
Purslow, Wanton Seed (1968) p.36
Journal of the Folk-Song Society 8 (1930) pp.188-190
Hubbard, Ballads & Songs from Utah pp.254-255
Baring-Gould, Songs of the West (1905 edn.) pp.46-47
Palmer, Oxford Book of Sea Songs (1986) pp.166-168
Frank Kidson MSS (Mitchell Lib. Glasgow); 'Traditional Tunes' (m18058) p.55
DOWNFALL OF PIRACY, THE Roud number 8115
audio: Veteran VT 115 ('In Horsham Town')
Frank, The New Book of Pirate Songs (2011) pp.45-47
ENGLAND'S TRIUMPH AND HOLLAND'S DOWNFALL; or, THE SECOND ROYAL VICTORY Roud number V1307
+++ NO TUNES
FAIR SALLY LOV'D A BONNY SAILOR Roud number V2837
Baring-Gould, English Minstrelsie 4 (1896) pp.118-120
FAMOUS SEA-FIGHT BETWEEN CAPTAIN WARD AND THE RAINBOW Roud number 224
-- 35 entries - these are some of them
O'Shaughnessey, Yellowbelly Ballads 1 pp.18-20, 68-70
Purslow, Wanton Seed (1968) p.24
Dawney, Ploughboy's Glory (1977) pp.38-39
Sharp, English County Folk Songs (1908-1912 / 1961) pp.72-75
Palmer, Folk Songs Collected by Ralph Vaughan Williams (1983) pp.86-88
Barrett, English Folk-Songs (1891) pp.62-63
FANCY FRIGATE, THE Roud number 2563
Palmer, Oxford Book of Sea Songs pp.204-206
Hugill, Shanties from the Seven Seas (1961) pp.462-463
Seeger & MacColl, Singing Island (1960) p.68
Shay, American Sea Songs & Chanteys (1948) pp.178-180
Palmer, Boxing the Compass (2001) pp.210-213
audio: Robert W. Gordon Collection (American Folklife Center, LOC) Cylinder 30 item CAL 62
Hugill, Bosun's Locker (2006) pp.116-118
FEMALE LIEUTENANT, THE; or, FAITHLESS LOVER REWARDED Roud number 158
-- 150 entries - these are some of them
Creighton, Songs & Ballads from Nova Scotia (1932) pp.64-65
Journal of the Folk-Song Society 5 (1915) pp.164-165
Greig-Duncan Collection 1 pp.438-441 (version a)
O'Shaughnessey, Yellowbelly Ballads 1 pp.13-14, 66-67
audio: Leader LEA 4050 (`Unto Brigg Fair')
Sharp, Folk Songs from Somerset 5 pp.46-47 (Version a)
HAWKE'S ENGAGEMENT Roud number 18256
+++ NO TUNES
HEARTS OF OAK Roud number V391
+++ NO TUNES
HOSIER'S GHOST Roud number 22377
Rimbault, Musical Illustrations of Bishop Percy's Reliques (1850) pp.30, 86
audio: JSP JSP 7768 ('When I Feel Froggie I'm Gonna Hop')
HUMOURS OF THE ROYAL BILLY, THE Roud number V3972
+++ NO TUNES
JOHN DORY Roud number 249
Dunstan, Cornish Song Book 1 (1929) p.10
Chappell, Popular Music of the Olden Time (1859 edn.) 1 pp.67-68
Smith, Music of the Waters (1888) pp.74-75
Frank, The New Book of Pirate Songs (2011) p.5
LOSS OF THE CENTAUR, THE Roud number V851
+++ NO TUNES
MAIDEN'S FROLICK, THE; or, A BRIEF RELATION HOW SIX LUSTY LASSES HAS PREST FULL FOURTEEN TAYLORS... Roud number V5616
+++ NO TUNES
NEWS FROM THE COAST OF SPAIN; or, A TRUE RELATION OF A BRISK AND BLOODY ENCOUNTER... Roud number V1994
+++ NO TUNES
NEW SONG COMPOSED BY THE WOUNDED TARS AT THE SIEGE OF BOULOGNE, A Roud number 3175
Stokoe & Reay, Songs & Ballads of Northern England (1899) pp.178-179
Palmer, Valiant Sailor (1973) p.46
Palmer, Oxford Book of Sea Songs (1986) pp.171-172
Palmer, Boxing the Compass (2001) pp.180-181
Palmer, Oxford Book of Sea Songs (1986) pp.171-172
OH CRUEL (ANSWER TO) Roud number V1837
+++ NO TUNES
OH CRUEL Roud number V1836
Scott, English Song Book (1926) pp.74-75
PAUL JONES Roud number 967
-- 30 entries - these are some of them
Barrett, English Folk-Songs (1891) pp.56-57
Purslow, Constant Lovers (1972) p.66
Warner, Traditional American Folk Songs (1980) pp.349-352
Richards & Stubbs, English Folksinger (1979) pp.160-161
Baring-Gould, Songs of the West (1905 edn.) pp.220-221
audio: Musical Traditions MT CD 313 ('The Broom Blooms Bonny')
ROYAL TRIUMPH, THE; or, THE UNSPEAKABLE JOY OF THE THREE KINGDOMS Roud number V1306
+++ NO TUNES
RUSSIANS WON'T COME OUT, THE Roud number V5353
+++ NO TUNES
SAILOR'S ONELY DELIGHT, THE Roud number 134
-- 54 entries - these are some of them
Warner, Traditional American Folk Songs (1980) pp.329-331
Karpeles, Cecil Sharp Collection 1 pp.209-210 (Version a)
audio: Folktracks FSA 047 (`Stormy Weather Boys')
Baring-Gould & Sharp, English Folk-Songs for Schools (1906) pp.18-19
Hugill, Shanties from the Seven Seas (1961) pp.419-421 (version b)
Anne Gilchrist MSS Collection (Vaughan Williams Memorial Library) AGG/3/135a
SAUCY SCYLLA, THE Roud number V4653
+++ NO TUNES
SHANNON AND CHESAPEAKE, THE Roud number 1583
-- 15 entries - these are some of them
Karpeles, Cecil Sharp Collection 2 pp.281-282
Fowke & Johnston, Folk Songs of Canada 1 (1954) pp.24-25
Whall, Sea Songs & Shanties (6th edn., 1927) pp.43-45
Harlow, Chanteying Aboard American Ships (1962) pp.187-188
Lomax, Folk Songs of North America (1960) p.49
Palmer, Oxford Book of Sea Songs (1986) pp.181-183
SIR ANDREW BARTON Roud number 104
-- 169 entries - these are some of them
audio: Folktracks FSA 047 (`Stormy Weather Boys')
Broadwood, English Traditional Songs & Carols (1908) pp.30-31, 117
O'Shaughnessey, Yellowbelly Ballads 1 pp.43-44, 79-80
Kidson, Traditional Tunes (1891) pp.29-32 (Version a)
Karpeles, Cecil Sharp Collection 1 pp.184-185 (Version a)
audio: Folkways FG 3507 / Topic TSCD 511 (`Now is the Time for Fishing')
SLAVE CHASE, THE Roud number 22376
Anne Gilchrist MSS Collection (Vaughan Williams Memorial Library) AGG/3/222d
TERRIBLE PRIVATEER, THE Roud number 9381
+++ NO TUNES
YE PARLIAMENT OF ENGLAND Roud number 2078
Colcord, Songs of American Sailormen (Oak Pubns edn) pp.124-126
Shay, American Sea Songs & Chanteys (1948) pp.158-160
audio: Helen Hartness Flanders Collection (Middlebury College, Vermont) D13 B 18