The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #28208   Message #352254
Posted By: Peter Kasin
06-Dec-00 - 05:45 AM
Thread Name: Lyr Req: Dirty Hog eye man?
Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Dirty Hog eye man?
I'll contact Celeste and ask her to check out this thread nd see if she might weigh in on it. Riggy sings Hogeye Man at the Hyde St. Pier chantey sings, and uses, as Troll mentioned, "Navvy" instead of "Nigger."

The dirty lyrics come out after 11pm at the chantey sings, as mentioned earlier, but under no circumstances is "nigger" sung. Offensive by any standard. On the issue of historical accuracy and public performance, isn't it historically accurate to just not sing the verse(s) with that word in them, and sing other verses instead? Every chanteyman picked his verses, had different versions, and made many versions up on the spot. As the saying goes: "Different ships, different long splices."

-chanteyranger