The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #150885   Message #3529757
Posted By: Jim Carroll
24-Jun-13 - 08:57 AM
Thread Name: BS: Unarmed soldier killed, (London-May 2013)
Subject: RE: BS: Unarmed soldier killed, Woolwich (London)
"It is an argument between you and Keith "
No it is not - it is a total rejection of the claim that there are any "Islamist communities" in Britain, one I would have made whoever made such a claim.
The fact that it is a lie is relevant as, to my knowledge Keith is the only member of this forum who consistently resorts to this practice.
"You have stated quite clearly that you believe the perpetrators were insane."
You fail to respond to the fact that my accusations are addressed to specific and continuing lies - what should I call somebody who persists in this practice.
No - I said that anybody who would carry out such a killing, for religious, or any other reason, must be insane. I also have taiken great pains to point out all the other possible reasons for such an act, carefully expunged from this discussion by those who would make it a religious killing - stop cherry-picking.
"'boy' does not appear in the DT version of the song"
Thank you Mike - it does in most of the versions I have heard - including that of Billy Bragg I seem to remember.
Jim Carroll