The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #151511   Message #3537040
Posted By: Jim McLean
13-Jul-13 - 01:31 PM
Thread Name: Red, Red Rose query
Subject: RE: Red, Red Rose query
You could be right, McGrath, but comparing a lady to a musical instrument, an object, doesn't seem like Burns. However the beauty of comparing her to a melody is much more poetic to my senses and something, I think, Burns would have done. Anyway, can we date A-roving on a cold, winter's night or the first mention of the instrument phrase pre 1794?