I actually think it's OK to challenge people who rarely or never post "up there" as to whether they actually have any interest in traditional music. It isn't right though, to insist that we're all musicians, and I imagine that could have been something that the poster of that remark might have wanted to correct. This is one website, not two. As I said, you can be interested in a lot of the activity there without necessarily posting much. I feel guilty at times that I can't find more to post about above the line but at least I've stated honestly where I am with all this.