The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #151520   Message #3544262
Posted By: Jim Carroll
01-Aug-13 - 08:11 AM
Thread Name: Folklore/History: Irish Famine
Subject: RE: Folklore/History: Irish Famine
You are attempting to deny the position you have taken here on both counts
I DENY I HAVE OBJECTED TO YOUR PUTTING ANY POINT OF VIEW
I DENY EVER HAVING OBJECTED TO ANYBODY PUTTING ANY POINT OF VIEW
I DENY EVER HAVING ATTEMPTED TO SUPPRESS OR CENSOR ANYTHING ON THIS FORUM AT ANY TIME OR ON ANY THREAD
HAVE YOU COMPLETELY FLIPPED - WHAT IS YOUR POINT - WHERE ARE YOU ATTEMPTING TO TAKE THIS?

You have, throughout this thread, attempted to absolve Britain from any blame whatever for the outcome of the Famine.
You have described those who disagree with you as "anti-British", "revisionsist", Irish Republican supporters, IRA supporters, 80 years out of date.... and a whole host of other things.
Your claims on Christine Kinealy's stance on this subject has totally fallen to pieces, so much so you appear to be arguing that her statement on Wike has been faked - "Do you know who wrote that Wiki page?"
You have been given another article by her saying the same thing, which you have totally failed to acknowledge
http://www.ballinagree.freeservers.com/knealy.html
You now appear to be blaming somebody else for putting something up that you have claimed to believe in - Grumpy in this case.
We appear to be back to Jack Straw and your claims of cultural implants.
You are a total mess, dishonest and self confessedly ignorant
What the hell is wrong with you.
If you can't argue on these subjects honestly, articulately and with some degree of genuine interest and knowledge - why bother attempting to dominate them the way you persist on doing?
You have insisted on having the last word on virtually every thread you have become involved in, you will no doubt do the same here.
If you know nothing of these subjects, find out about them - that is what debate should be about.
Jim Carroll