The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #152354 Message #3563930
Posted By: Jack Campin
03-Oct-13 - 09:18 AM
Thread Name: Traditional Music: Where are we going wrong?
Subject: RE: Traditional Music: Where are we going wrong?
And Lighter, I have agree about rap. In fact, I feel sorry for kids who have been led to believe that it is anything approaching that which could be called music. It is angry hateful degrading garbage. It's something much more sinister than can be explained by the usual "generation gap."
I take it that means you agree with your Greek Nazi pals that rappers ought to be shot?
Rap has become an international expression of popular resistance. It's been the most important progressive musical phenomenon exported from the US in the last generation.
Both Ireland and Scotland, for example, suffered from years of cultural oppression
Most of the cultural oppression Scotland suffered was at the hands of the Scottish power elite, the Kirk in particular. Scottish song and instrumental music thrived after the Union, precisely because it was a secular symbol of national identity.
The same was mostly true of Ireland - the worst enemy Irish music had was the Irish Catholic priesthood, not the British colonizers.