Dave - the point is, I did accept it;

Not really, Craigie. This thread show that you have far from accepted it and your further justifications in lambasting your critic seem to indicate that they did touch a nerve.

Please don't get me wrong - I am not criticising you or your singing. I don't know either. Just saying that it does look like you subsequently decided not to accept the criticism and created this thread accordingly. I think the best thing you can do is make a joke of it. Next time you are there purposely look the critic in the and say something like 'I am sure (insert name) will tell me where I am going wrong'.

Hope this helps and please don't take offence at my remarks. You did invite viewpoints and suggestions and these are mine.

Cheers

DtG