Other discussions here make me think that "Red Is the Rose" may also have come from Scotland, altered slightly when it was taken up by those plucky Irishers....
-Joe-

---

Not that there's agreement, of course - see this thread (click), in which Malcolm Douglas thought "Red Is the Rose" had 20th century Irish origins, while nutty posted this:

Thread #7171   Message #910601
Posted By: nutty
15-Mar-03 - 08:10 AM
Thread Name: Origin: Red Is the Rose
Subject: RE: Red Is The Rose

This site has what I have always believed was the traditional version if 'Red is the Rose'. Not an Irish Connection in sight.

Red is the rose

There is also a MIDI

      Red is The Rose

Over the mountains and down in the glen,
To a little thatched cot in the valley;
Where the thrush and the linnet sing their ditty and their song,
And my love's leaning over the half-door.

Chorus:
Red is the rose that in yonder garden grows,
Fair is the lily of the valley;
Clear are the waters that flow in yonder stream,
But my love is fairer than any.

Down by the seashore on a cool summer's eve,
With the moon rising over the heather;
The moon it shown fair on her head of golden hair,
And she vowed she'd be my love forever.

It is not for the loss of my own sister Kate,
It is not for the loss of my mother;
It is all for the loss of my bonnie blue-eyed lass,
That I'm leaving my homeland forever.

Chorus:
Red is the rose that in yonder garden grows,
Fair is the lily of the valley;
Clear are the waters that flow in yonder stream,
But my love is fairer than any;
But my love is fairer than any.